In a 2012 episode of Oprah’s Lifeclass show, Oprah told her audience that her producers had received a letter from a woman in the United Kingdom, Shelly-Ann (not her real name), about her addiction to online gambling that would likely cause the end of her marriage.
Married for only a year, Shelly-Ann informed Oprah, her co-host Iyanla Vanzant, and the show’s studio and tv audiences via phone interview that she had gambled away more than 50,000 British pounds (about $53, 500 in today’s U.S. currency), the money her husband was saving for a down payment on a new home. Seven months pregnant and under bed rest, she didn’t know how to tell her husband what she’d done.
Obviously in deep distress, Shelly-Ann had reached out to the Oprah show for advice on how to deal with the consequences of her actions, including the likelihood of her marriage ending. After Oprah read Shelly-Ann’s letter, which concluded with her saying that she didn’t have a clue to how to repair the damage she had done, Iyanla said “Me either, girl.”
What happened next stunned me. I watched in disbelief as first Iyanla and then Oprah broke out into out into bout of raucous laughter. After their laughter subsided enough for them to talk, Iyanla who clearly has no experience dealing with anyone with a gambling addiction, went on to tell Shelly-Ann that her “baby is marinating in a toxic womb, a womb filled of fear and shame, and that’s what’s being fed, woven into the fiber of that child’s being” and other such nonsense, with Oprah agreeing with her. Here is the video.
Although they finally got around to giving Shelly-Ann advice, such as it was, I couldn’t help but wonder as I watched the video, “Where is the empathy? The compassion? I also wondered, “What if that had been me? Or Gladys Knight, who struggled with a gambling addiction for years? Would they have laughed like that at us too?
I confess that I’ve never liked Iyanla Vanzant. I don’t think her way of dealing with people in crisis is helpful, and certainly not for a woman seeking help for a gambling addiction. As someone who also experienced a near devastating gambling addiction, I felt that Sherry-Ann didn’t deserve this kind of judgemental and condescending treatment. I wished she had just ended her call.
It hurts me to watch this show, which I’ve had to do a few times to write this post. Iyanla and Oprah’s behavior probably did more damage than good in terms of encouraging other women to reach out for help with their gambling problems before they destroy their lives and those of their loved ones. And that makes me very sad.